Tooth-Coloured Fillings vs Amalgam Fillings: Which Is Right for You?

Patient having a routine dental check-up

Tooth coloured fillings are made from composite resin or glass ionomer that is bonded to the tooth and matched to its shade, while amalgam fillings are a silver-grey metal alloy held in place by the shape of the cavity. For most small to medium cavities today, a tooth-coloured composite filling is the usual first choice.

Key Takeaways

  • Composite fillings bond to the tooth, so the dentist usually needs to remove less healthy tooth structure than for amalgam.
  • Amalgam is strong and tolerant of moisture, but it is visible, contains mercury and is being phased down internationally.
  • Health authorities do not advise removing intact amalgam fillings purely for health reasons, as drilling them out releases more mercury vapour.
  • Glass ionomer, a third tooth-coloured option, releases fluoride and is often used for children, root surfaces and temporary repairs.
  • The right material depends on the size and position of the cavity, your bite and your medical history, which a dentist assesses in person.

What Is the Difference Between Tooth-Coloured and Amalgam Fillings?

A filling replaces tooth structure lost to decay, wear or a small fracture. Once the dentist has removed the decayed part of the tooth, the space is sealed with a filling material so that bacteria cannot get back in and the tooth can chew normally again.

Tooth-coloured fillings

The most common tooth-coloured material is composite resin, a mixture of plastic resin and fine glass or ceramic particles. It is placed in layers, shaped to the tooth and hardened with a curing light. Because it is glued to the enamel and dentine with an adhesive, it does not rely on the cavity having a particular shape.

Glass ionomer is a second tooth-coloured material. It sticks to the tooth chemically and slowly releases fluoride, but it is less wear resistant than composite, so it is mostly used where biting forces are low.

Amalgam fillings

Dental amalgam is an alloy of liquid mercury with a powder of silver, tin and copper. It is packed into the cavity while soft and sets hard within minutes. Amalgam does not bond to the tooth, so the dentist shapes the cavity with undercuts that lock the filling in place. This usually means removing some healthy tooth along with the decay.

You can learn more about the materials and steps involved on our dental filling treatment page.

How Do the Two Materials Compare?

Both materials can work well when placed in the right situation. The table summarises the main practical differences.

特点 Composite (tooth-coloured) Amalgam (silver)
外观 Matched to the natural tooth shade Silver-grey, can darken and give the tooth a grey tint
How it stays in Bonded to the tooth with an adhesive Held mechanically by the shape of the cavity
Tooth removal needed Usually less; mainly the decay itself Usually more, to create retention
Placement Needs a dry tooth and more chair time Quicker and more tolerant of moisture
Wear and strength Good for most fillings; can chip or stain at the edges over time Very hard wearing in large back-tooth fillings
Repairs Small defects can often be added to and repaired Usually needs full replacement if it fails
Mercury None Contains mercury bound in the alloy

In short, composite is chosen for appearance and tooth conservation, while amalgam has traditionally been chosen for durability in large fillings where keeping the tooth dry is difficult.

Are Amalgam Fillings Safe?

Amalgam fillings release very small amounts of mercury vapour, mainly during placement, removal and heavy chewing or grinding. Health regulators such as the US Food and Drug Administration consider intact amalgam fillings safe for most adults and children over six.

In 2020 the US Food and Drug Administration recommended that some higher-risk groups avoid new amalgam fillings where suitable alternatives exist. These groups include:

  • pregnant women and women planning a pregnancy
  • breastfeeding mothers
  • children under six
  • people with kidney problems or certain neurological conditions
  • people with a known allergy to mercury or other amalgam components

Separately, the Minamata Convention on Mercury, an international treaty, asks countries to phase down the use of dental amalgam, largely because of mercury released into the environment. The European Union ended most routine use of amalgam from 2025. These moves are a big reason why tooth-coloured materials have become the default in many clinics.

Which Filling Suits Which Situation?

There is no single right answer for every tooth. The dentist weighs where the cavity is, how big it is and how much biting force the tooth takes.

Front teeth and visible areas

Composite is the clear choice for front teeth and any area that shows when you smile or talk. It can also be used to repair small chips. If you are mainly interested in reshaping front teeth for appearance, our article on dental bonding vs veneers explains the cosmetic options.

Small and medium cavities in back teeth

For most cavities in premolars and molars, modern composite performs well and preserves more of the tooth. Early decay caught at the first signs of a cavity can often be repaired with a small, conservative composite filling.

Very large cavities

When more than about half of the tooth is missing, a large filling of any material is more likely to crack the remaining walls. In these cases the dentist may suggest an onlay or a crown instead of a filling, to protect the tooth from splitting.

Children and root surfaces

Glass ionomer is often used in baby teeth, near the gumline and on exposed roots in older adults, because its fluoride release helps resist new decay and it tolerates a slightly moist surface.

Should You Replace Old Amalgam Fillings?

Many adults in Kuala Lumpur still have amalgam fillings placed years ago. If a filling is intact, sealed and not causing problems, it usually does not need to be replaced. Removing a sound amalgam filling takes away more tooth and briefly releases more mercury vapour than leaving it alone.

Replacement is usually considered when:

  • there is new decay under or beside the filling
  • the filling is cracked, chipped or leaking at its edges
  • the tooth itself has a crack line next to the filling
  • the filling causes ongoing sensitivity or discomfort
  • you want to change visible silver fillings for cosmetic reasons, after discussing the pros and cons

When amalgam is removed, dentists use high-volume suction and water spray to limit vapour and debris. Ask how this is managed if you plan to have several fillings replaced.

What Happens When You Get a Tooth-Coloured Filling?

A composite filling is usually completed in a single visit. The steps are broadly as follows:

  1. The dentist examines the tooth and may take an X-ray to see how deep the decay goes.
  2. Local anaesthetic is given if the cavity is near the nerve or the tooth is sensitive.
  3. Decay is removed and the tooth is kept dry, often with cotton rolls or a thin rubber sheet called a dental dam.
  4. The tooth surface is conditioned and an adhesive is applied and light cured.
  5. Composite is placed in thin layers, each hardened with the curing light, then shaped to your bite.
  6. The filling is checked with articulating paper and polished smooth.

Mild sensitivity to cold or biting for a few days is common after a deeper filling. If sensitivity lasts beyond two weeks, or the tooth throbs on its own, contact your dentist, as the nerve may be irritated. Our guide on sensitive teeth covers other common causes.

How Long Do Fillings Last and How Do You Look After Them?

Composite and amalgam fillings commonly last many years, but lifespan varies widely with the size of the filling, your bite, grinding habits and how well the area is cleaned. Large fillings in heavily loaded molars generally need attention sooner than small ones.

To help fillings last longer:

  • brush twice daily with a fluoride toothpaste and clean between teeth every day
  • limit sugary drinks and snacks between meals, including sweetened teh tarik and bubble tea
  • avoid biting on ice, bones or hard shells
  • ask about a night guard if you clench or grind
  • attend regular check-ups so worn edges can be repaired early

Book a Consultation at Urban Dental

Urban Dental provides dental fillings, including tooth-coloured fillings, and can check existing fillings for wear, leakage or new decay. The choice of filling material depends on a clinical assessment, and a particular treatment may not be suitable for everyone.

Visit us at Lot L1-17 & L1-18, First Floor, DC Mall (Damansara City Mall), 6 Jalan Damanlela, Bukit Damansara, 50490 Kuala Lumpur. Call 03-2080 0887 or WhatsApp 012-994 1668, or book a consultation at our DC Mall clinic. Fees depend on the number and size of fillings, and you can ask for an itemised quotation after your examination.

常见问题

Are tooth coloured fillings as strong as amalgam?

Modern composite is strong enough for most small and medium fillings in both front and back teeth. Amalgam can be more wear resistant in very large back-tooth fillings, but in those cases a dentist will often recommend an onlay or crown instead, because a large filling of any material leaves the remaining tooth walls weaker.

Should I remove my silver fillings?

Not if they are intact and not causing problems. Health authorities do not recommend removing sound amalgam fillings purely for health reasons, as removal takes away more tooth and releases more mercury vapour. Replacement makes sense when a filling is cracked, leaking or has new decay around it, or for cosmetic reasons after discussion.

Does getting a composite filling hurt?

Most people feel pressure and vibration rather than pain, because local anaesthetic is used when the cavity is deep or the tooth is sensitive. Some cold or biting sensitivity is common for a few days afterwards. Sensitivity that lasts longer than about two weeks should be checked by your dentist.

Can I eat straight after a tooth coloured filling?

Composite is fully hardened by the curing light before you leave the chair, so the filling itself is ready to chew on. If you had local anaesthetic, wait until the numbness wears off, usually after two to three hours, so that you do not bite your cheek, lip or tongue by accident.

Do tooth coloured fillings stain?

Composite is fairly stain resistant, but the surface and edges can pick up colour over time from coffee, tea, curry and smoking. Regular brushing, professional polishing during check-ups and avoiding tobacco help. Composite does not lighten with whitening, so anyone planning whitening should usually do it before having visible fillings matched.

This article is general information and does not replace a dental examination. Speak to a dentist about your own situation.

在线预约

Enhance Your Smile with Professional Whitening

Lobortis ut aptent metus hac ad. Risus morbi ut tellus suspendisse lectus platea.

关注我们: